经济理论与经济管理 ›› 2023, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (7): 47-59.

• • 上一篇    下一篇

宗族网络、行政干预与村民安全感*——基于全国27省份212个村庄的证据

  

  1. 1  南京农业大学经济管理学院;   2  华南农业大学国家农业制度与发展研究院。
  • 出版日期:2023-07-16 发布日期:2023-08-11
  • 基金资助:
    本文得到国家自然科学基金重点项目(71933004)、中国博士后科学基金项目(2021M702701)和国家社科基金后期资助项目(20FGLA004)的资助。

CLAN NETWORKS,ADMINISTRATIV INTERVENTION AND VILLAGERS'SENSE OF SECURITY——Evidence from 212 Villages in 27 Provinces

  1. 1College of Economics and Management,Nanjing Agricultural University of China;
    2NSAID,South China Agricultural University of China
  • Online:2023-07-16 Published:2023-08-11

摘要: 提升村民安全感是实现基层善治、推动乡村振兴的核心目标之一。作为维系传统社会的重要组织力量,宗族因妨害民主自治、威胁村民安全而被诟病。但村庄社会的分散性与自发性使得行政规治面临着高昂的治理成本,故利用非正式组织自我执行机制并发挥其治理潜能,有助于重构乡村秩序。本文利用2016年中国劳动力动态调查数据分析了宗族网络和行政干预对村民安全感的影响。结果显示,宗族网络力量过大或过于集中降低了村民安全感。进一步证据表明,行政干预虽然能够抑制宗族俘获村庄治权,但其依然不利于村民安全感的提升。当行政干预与宗族网络同时存在时,村民安全感得到了有效提升。这表明,宗族网络与行政干预均为“双刃剑”,只有保证二者的协同才能助力基层治理有效。对于远离行政中心、地处山区的村庄,宗族网络是维持社会秩序、保障村庄安全的重要组织力量。本文旨在说明,发挥正式组织与非正式组织两个方面的积极性,寻求两种力量的均衡与协调,是提升村民安全感的重要策略。


关键词: 安全感, 宗族网络, 行政干预, 基层治理

Abstract: Improving villagers sense of security is one of the most important targets of realizing great grassroots governance and promoting rural revitalization As an important organizational force to maintain the traditional society,clans are often criticized for interfering with democratic autonomy and threatening villagers safety However,due to the decentralization and spontaneity of village society,administrative regulation is faced with high governance costs Therefore,making good use of the selfexecutive mechanism of informal organizations and giving full play to their governance potentials will help reconstruct the rural order This paper uses the data from the 2016 China Labor Dynamic Survey to investigate the impacts of clan power and administrative governance on villagers sense of security The results indicate that excess or concentration of clan power reduces villagers sense of security Further analysis shows that although administrative intervention prevents clans from capturing village governance,it still reduces villagers sense of security When both administrative governance and clan power exist,villagers sense of security is increased This evidence indicates that both administrative governance and clan power are doubleedged swords,and only ensuring the harmony of them can help grassroots governance Additionally,in the villages far from countylevel administrative center or located in mountainous areas,clans are an important organizational power to maintain social order and ensure villages safety Our analysis implies that to give full play to the enthusiasm of formal organizations and informal organizations and seek the balance and coordination of the two forces is an important strategy to improve villagers sense of security


Key words: sense of security, clan network, administrative intervention, grassroots governance