税式支出研究的新进展

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 本文重点阐述税式支出的理论分析框架及其实际效应,以作为后续相关研究的基础。税式支出既具有激励保障功能,又存在诸多弊端。因此,扩大还是限制税式支出,从未停止过争论。理论研究发现,税式支出存在最优规模,具有促进就业和改善收入分配的积极效应,并且与政治体制、社会选择紧密相关。经验研究发现,税式支出对个人决策、产业发展和政府行为产生了多重影响。

关键词: 税式支出, 税收优惠, 理论框架, 实际效应

Abstract: This paper is a literature review on the study of tax expenditures,focused on the theoretical framework and the real effects.Debates on encouraging or restraining tax expenditures would never cease due to their positive functions and negative influence.Theoretical studies indicated that the optimal level of tax expenditures achieved by considering economic efficiency could stimulate employment and improve the income distribution,closely link up with the political systems and social choices.Relevant empirical research found that there are multiple effects of tax expenditures on individual and government behaviors as well as industry development.

Key words: tax expenditure, tax preference, theoretical framework, real effects

中图分类号:

F810.42

毛捷. 税式支出研究的新进展[J]. 经济理论与经济管理, 2011, 31(5): 42-50.

MAO Jie. NEWLY RESEARCH ON TAX EXPENDITURES[J]. Economic Theory and Business Management, 2011, 31(5): 42-50.

参考文献

[1] 白重恩,毛捷.公共财政视角下的税式支出管理与预算体制改革[J].中国财政,2011,(2).
[2] 邓子基.税式支出管理[M].北京:中国经济出版社,1996.
[3] 刘心一.税式支出分析[M].北京:中国财政经济出版社,1996.
[4] 刘蓉.税式支出的经济分析[M].成都:西南财经大学出版社,2000.
[5] 楼继伟,解学智.税式支出理论创新与制度探索[M].北京:中国财政经济出版社,2003.
[6] 孙钢,许文.关于我国实行税式支出预算管理的初步研究[EB/OL].http://www.crifs.org.cn/0416show.asp?art_id=147,2011-01-26.
[7] 张晋武.中国税式支出制度构建研究[M].北京:人民出版社,2008.
[8] 崔军,高培勇.调节收入分配的税式支出政策[J].经济理论与经济管理,2004,(1).
[9] 万莹.税式支出的效应分析与绩效评价[M].北京:中国经济出版社,2006.
[10] S.S.Surrey.Tax Incentives as a Device for Implementing Government Policy:A Comparison with Direct Government Expenditures[J].Harvard Law Review,1970,83 (4).
[11] B.I.Bittker.Accounting for Federal "Tax Subsidies" in the National Budget[J].National Tax Journal,1969,22(2).
[12] S.Fiekowsky.The Relation of Tax Expenditures to the Distribution of the "Fiscal Burden"[J].Canadian Taxation,1980,(2).
[13] V.Thuronyi.Tax Expenditures:A Reassessment[J].Duke Law Journal,1988,(6).
[14] V.Bratié.Tax Expenditures..A Theoretical Review[J].Financial Theory and Practice,2006,30 (2).
[15] S.S.Surrey.Federal Income Tax Reform..The Varied Approaches Necessary to Replace Tax Expenditures with Direct Governmental Assistance[J].Harvard Law Review,1970,84 (2).
[16] N.Eissa,H.Hoynes.Redistribution and Tax Expenditures..The Earned Income Tax Credit[Z].NBER Working Paper,No.14 307,2008.
[17] J.Gruber.The Tax Exclusion for Employer-sponsored Health Insurance[Z].NBER Working Paper,No.15 766,2010.
[18] E.Saez.The Optimal Treatment of Tax Expenditures[J].Journal of Public Economics,2004,(88).
[19] K.Scharf.Why Are Tax Expenditures for Giving Embodied in Fiscal Constitutions?[J].Journal of Public Economics,2000,(75).
[20] D.Dharmapala.Comparing Tax Expenditures and Direct Subsides:The Role of Legislative Committee Structure[J].Journal of Public Economics,1999,(72).
[21] M.V.Pauly.Taxation,Health Insurance,and Market Failure in the Medical Economy[J].Journal of Economic Literature,1986,(24).
[22] J.Gruber,J.Poterba.Tax Incentives and the Decision to Purchase Health Insurance:Evidence from the Self-Employed[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,1994,109 (3).
[23] S.L.Averett,H.E.Peters,D.M.Waldman.Tax Credits,Labor Supply,and Child Care[J].Review of Economics and Statistics,1997,79 (1).
[24] N.Eissa,H.W.Hoynes.Taxes and the Labor Market Participation of Married Couples:The Earned Income Tax Credit[J].Journal of Public Economics,2004,(88).
[25] M.Brewer,A.Duncan,A.Shephard,M.J.Suárez.Did Working Families' Tax Credit Work? The Impact of InWork Support Labour Supply in Great Britain[J].Labour Economics,2006,(13).
[26] S.Hamersma.The Effects of an Employer Subsidy on Employment Outcomes:A Study of the Work Opportunity and Welfare-to-Work Tax Credits[J].Journal of Policy Analysis and Management,2008,27 (3).
[27] R.Chetty,E.Saez.Teaching the Tax Code..Earnings Responses to an Experiment with EITC Recipients[Z].NBER Working Paper,No.14 836,2009.
[28] F.Hayashi.Consumption and Liquidity Constraints..A Critical Survey[Z].NBER Working Paper,No.1 720,1985.
[29] E.M.Engen,W.G.Gale,J.K.Scholz.Do Saving Incentives Work?[J].Brookings Papers on Economic Activity,1994,(1).
[30] J.M.Poterba,S.F.Venti,D.A.Wise.Do 401 (k) Contributions Crowd out Other Personal Saving?[J].Journal of Public Economics,1995,(58).
[31] N.S.Souleles.The Response of Household Consumption to Income Tax Refunds[J].American Economic Review,1999,(89).
[32] M.D.Shapiro,J.B.Slemrod.Consumer Response to Tax Rebates[J].American Economic Review,2003,(93).
[33] D.S.Johnson,J.A.Parker,N.S.Souleles.Household Expenditure and the Income Tax Rebates of 2001[J].American Economic Review,2006,(96).
[34] S.Agarwal,Chunlin Liu,N.S.Souleles.The Reaction of Consumer Spending and Debt to Tax Rebates-Evidence from Consumer Credit Data[J].Journal of Political Economy,2007,115 (6).
[35] M.Shapiro,J.Slemrod.Did the 2008 Tax Rebates Stimulate Spending?[J].American Economic Review,2009,99(2).
[36] Yonghong Wu.The Effects of State R&D Tax Credits in Stimulating Private R&D Expenditure..A Cross-state Empirical Analysis[J].Journal of Policy Analysis and Management,2005,24 (4).
[37] D.Hanlon,S.Pinder.An Empirical Investigation of Whether Australian Capital Gains Tax Reforms Influence Individual Investor Behaviour[J].Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,2007,(15).
[38] W.S.Reece,K.D.Zieschang.Consistent Estimation of the Impact of Tax Deductibility on the Level of Charitable[J].Econometrica,1985,53 (2).
[39] G.Glenday,A.K.Gupta,H.Pawlak.Tax Incentives for Personal Charitable Contributions[J].Review of Economics and Statistics,1986,68 (4).
[40] A.M.Jones,J.W.Posnett.The Impact of Tax Deductibility on Charitable Giving by Covenant in the UK[J].Economic Journal,1991,(101).
[41] K.Scharf,S.Smith.The Price Elasticity of Charitable Giving:Does the Form of Tax Relief Matter?[Z].IFS Working Paper,No.W10/07,2010.
[42] S.Malpezzi,K.Vandell.Does the Low-income Housing Tax Credit Increase the Supply of Housing[J].Journal of Housing Economics,2002,(11).
[43] M.Desai,D.Dharmapala,M.Singhal.Investable Tax Credi:The Case of the Low Income Housing Tax Credit[Z].NBER Working Paper,No.14 149,2008.
[44] J.Poterba,T.Sinai.Tax Expenditures for Owner-occupied Housing..Deductions for Property Taxes and Mortgage Interest and the Exclusion of Imputed Rental Income[J].American Economic Review,2008,98 (2).
[45] R.L.McDonald.Cross-border Investing with Tax Arbitrage:The Case of German Dividend Tax Credits[J].Review of Financial Studies,2001,14 (3).
[46] D.Cannavan,F.Finn,S.Gray.The Value of Dividend Imputation Tax Credits in Australia[J].Journal of Financial Economics,2004,(73).
[47] J.A.Dubin,S.D.Henson.The Distributional Effects of the Federal Energy Tax Act[J].Resources and Energy,1988,(10).
[48] M.J.Walsh.Energy Tax Credits and Housing Improvement[J].Energy Economics,1989,11 (4).
[49] K.A.Hasset,G.E.Metcalf.Energy Tax Credits and Residential Conservation Investnent..Evidence from Panel Data[J].Journal of Public Economics,1995,(57).
[50] R.Wiser,M.Bolinger,G.Barbose.Using the Federal Production Tax Credit to Build a Durable Market for Wind Power in the United States[J].Electricity Journal,2007,20 (9).
[51] G.Metcalf.Investment in Energy Infrastructure and the Tax Code[J].Tax Policy and the Economy,2009,(24).
[52] G.Metcalf.Tax Policies for Low-carbon Technologies[Z].NBER Working Paper,No.15 054,2009.
[53] M.Feldstein,G.EVMetcalf.The Effect of Federal Tax Deductibility on State and Local Taxes and Spending[J].Journal of Political Economy,1987,95 (4).
[54] D.Holtz-Eakin,H.S.Rosen.Federal Deductibility and Local Property Tax Rates[J].Journal of Urban Economics,1990,27 (3).
[55] N.A.Noto,D.Zimmerman.Limiting State-local Tax Deductibility:Effects among the States[J].National Tax Journal,1984,37 (4).
[56] G.E.Metcalf.Assessing the Federal Deduction for State and Local Tax Payments[Z].NBER Working Paper,No.14 023,2008.