Loading...

Table of Content

    16 July 2024, Volume 44 Issue 7
    Judicial Delocalization and Firm-evel Total Factor Productivity:Evidence from the Establishment of Circuit Courts by the Supreme People's Court
    SONG Chang1, HE Shuoying1, BI Gongbing2, HENG Xiaogang2
    2024, 44(7):  1-14. 
    Asbtract ( )   PDF (8948KB) ( )  
    Related Articles | Metrics
    Highquality rule of law is an important safeguard for accelerating the formation and development of Chinas new quality productive forces The problem of “localization” of justice is not conducive to achieving judicial justice,is a manifestation of local protection, and obstructs the effective allocation of market resources The establishment of circuit courts by the Supreme Peoples Court is an important judicial system reform for this purpose in China This paper uses a staggered DID model to explore the impact of the establishment of circuit courts on the firmlevel total factor productivity (TFP),examing the effect of judicial “delocalization” institutional innovation on the efficiency of resource allocation  from the microenterprise level
    The results show that: (1) Circuit courts significantly improve TFP,which is equivalent to 21% of the average TFP of sample firms (2) This positive effect is more obvious for firms with stateownership,largescale privateownership and governmentsubsidized,those are more likely to benefit from local protection (3) Alleviating regional market segmentation,improving the efficiency of regional contract execution and restraining firms overinvestment are the possible mechanisms for circuit courts to improve firms TFP (4)Whether the location of a firm is the location of the circuit court does not affect the promotion effect of the circuit court on the firms TFP,which to some extent indicates that the circuit courts “residence + circuit region” form is effective
    This paper provides new evidence for the argument that promoting the construction of the rule of law in China is conducive to highquality economic development Based on the findings of our research,we propose the following policy recommendations Firstly,on the path of building the rule of law in China,we should continue to deepen the reform of the judicial system and institutions,further safeguard judicial fairness,and enhance the quality of justice Secondly,in advancing the strategy of highquality economic development,great emphasis should be placed on the development of new quality productive forces,while implementing technological innovations and driving industrial transformation,it is essential to enhance the efficiency of resource allocation among market microentities Thirdly,in the process of accelerating the construction of a unified national market,we should fundamentally address the relationship between the government and the market in terms of systems and mechanisms,and effectively ensure that the market plays a decisive role in resource allocation

    Deregulation of Market Access and Labor Income Share
    LI Jinlei1, WANG Lei1, HUANG Yuanbiao2
    2024, 44(7):  15-32. 
    Asbtract ( )   PDF (10788KB) ( )  
    Related Articles | Metrics
    China has created a liberalized market environment by improving market access regulations and providing favorable conditions for business operationsWhile deregulating market access stimulates market vitality,the equitable distribution of development gains remains a critical issueLabor income share,which measures the proportion of national income allocated to labor,reflects the fairness of income distributionIncreasing labor income share is crucial to ensuring that workers fairly share in economic development gainsWe employ the market access negative list system as a quasinatural experiment and constructs a DID model to empirically examine the impact and mechanisms of deregulating market access on firms labor income shares
    The findings indicate that deregulating market access significantly enhances firms labor income sharesThis conclusion holds robustly across parallel trend tests,heterogeneous treatment effect analyses,and considerations of the nonrandomness of policy pilotsImportantly,this increase does not result from the redistribution of labor income among firmsMechanism analysis reveals that deregulation directly facilitates the entry of market entities,which,in turn,enhances firms labor income shares by affecting their monopoly power,innovation investments,and investment activitiesFurther research shows that the primary source of increased labor income share is the improvement in wages for highskilled employees rather than an increase in their numbersMoreover,deregulating market access promotes fair income distribution among labor factors within firms,thereby reducing income disparitiesHeterogeneity analysis demonstrates that the positive impact of deregulating market access on labor income shares is more pronounced for firms in regions with high levels of government intervention,manufacturing firms,and nonstateowned enterprises
    The marginal contributions of this study are as follows:First,it integrates the market access negative list system with firms labor income shares within a unified analytical framework,linking market access regulations with internal income distribution in firms and enriching the literature on market access systemsSecond,from the perspective of market institutions,it broadens the research on factors influencing firms labor income sharesExisting studies have yet to focus on the impact of market access regulations on labor income sharesBy examining the market access negative list systems role in enhancing labor income shares,this study provides new insights for adjusting income distribution and improving labor remuneration
    Theoretical and empirical evidence from this study reveals that deregulating market access is a significant factor influencing firms labor income shares,offering clear policy implicationsThe Chinese government should further deepen the market access negative list system,enhance highlevel coordination,and continuously and thoroughly promote the implementation of the “nonprohibited entry” principleThis will help build a higherlevel market economy system and continuously unleash market vitality

    Does Market Crowd Out Trust:An Experimental Investigation
    CHEN Yefeng1, WANG Jiarui2, DING Yuli3, PAN Yiwen3, WU Xianghua4
    2024, 44(7):  33-49. 
    Asbtract ( )   PDF (11558KB) ( )  
    Related Articles | Metrics
    The research question of this paper is:Does the market crowd out peoples trust? Which characteristics of the market influence peoples trust? Causally addressing these questions requires comparing the differences in trust between environments with and without markets However,it is difficult to obtain empirical data on the nomarket environment Experimental methods provide a new solution,thanks to a nomarket scenario we can simulate in the laboratory
    The experimental design faces two challenges First,what type of game can characterize both the market and trust? We adopt the trust game in experience goods markets,where firms know the quality of the goods they sell,but consumers do not know the quality before purchasing The information asymmetry makes trust crucial in experience goods markets,which is why we choose it as our baseline game Second, how can we define the market or characterize its features? We view competition as the core of the market Based on decentralized mechanism of market rights,we further decompose free competition into two aspects:(1) consumer choice:consumers have the right to freely choose the goods they trade;(2) seller pricing power:sellers in the market have the right to set prices for their goods Finally,we consider the market narrative as another characteristic of the market
    Following the above research pipeline,we use the trust game in experience goods markets as the “market” environment,and create a similar game structure as the “nomarket” environment,thereby comparing the differences in trust The “nomarket” environment lacks features such as consumer choice,seller pricing power,or market narrative We set up treatments that remove single,double,or triple features to analyze the individual and combined effects of market features on trust We also use withinsubject design and data migrating techniques to make sure the decision environment is completely replicated,with only the presence or absence of the market features changing 
    Our results indicate that the market does not crowd out peoples trust The impact of consumer choice and seller pricing power on trust is asymmetric,with consumer choice playing a crucial role Additional mediation analysis shows that reputation is an important channel in how market factors determining peoples trust

    The U-shaped Impact of Digital Government Development on Income Inequality:Global Evidence
    XU Xianxiang1, 2, ZHOU Quan1, 2, GE Erqi1, CHEN Xilu1
    2024, 44(7):  50-71. 
    Asbtract ( )   PDF (12483KB) ( )  
    Related Articles | Metrics
    We systematically estimate the causal effects of digital government development on income inequality Initially,we elaborate on the impact of digital government on income inequality through a conceptual quantitative model Specifically,the initial introduction of digital government enhances the standardization and transparency of public service application processes,reducing the costs for firms to access public services The gap among firms in their ability to apply for public services is then narrowed,reducing the inequality in firm profitability Nonetheless,with the progressive maturation of digital government functionalities,some firms may encounter limitations in fully leveraging online public services due to variances in scale,geographical location,human capital,and other determinants,leading to the phenomenon known as the “digital divide,” thus widening income disparities
    Using data from 158 economies worldwide from 2007 to 2019,we first employ fixed effects regressions to explore the correlation between digital government development and income inequality However,due to the inherent endogeneity of digital government construction and its close association with the overall economic development level,the fixed effects regressions suffer from bias To address the endogeneities,we further construct instrumental variables for digital government development by interacting with the average historical birth rates between 1950 and 1955 and time trend Our two stage least squares results then show that the influence of digital government follows a Ushaped pattern To be specific,digital government widens income inequality in the top 50% of countries but reduces it in the remaining 50%
    We aim to delve deeper into the impact of digital government on income inequality both before and after government redistribution as mechanism explorations We utilize the Gini coefficient based on pretax and pretransfer income data from the SWIID database to gauge income inequality prior to government redistribution Comparative analysis of the regression outcomes from this exercise with our baseline results suggests the redistribution does not affect the Upattern Our conclusions are highly robust After altering variable measurements,modifying model specifications,and incorporating additional control variables,the observed Ushaped pattern in the impact of digital government development on income inequality remains unchanged
    To mitigate the potential widening of income disparity in China posed by digital government development,we propose two policy recommendations First,during the construction of digital government,Chinese government should focus on expanding the coverage of digital technologies and enhancing the precision of public services,enabling as many people as possible to access government services through digital platforms,thus achieving equalization of public services and bridging the digital divide effectively Second,Chinese government should further broaden and deepen the application of digital technologies in the income redistribution process
    Our study underscores three significant contributions First,we extend the research on the influence of information and communication technology on income inequality from the perspective of digital government Second,we identify the heterogeneous impact of digital government on income distribution at different stages of development Thirdly,we provide credible empirical evidence concerning the influence of digital government on inclusive income growth through crossnational data analysis Our findings offer insights into the systemic impact of digital government on income inequality,providing new policy pathways for promoting common prosperity in China

    The Wage Premium for State-owned Enterprise Employees and Its Formation Mechanism 
    SONG Yang1, 2, SHI Yaocheng1, HOU Guangsu3
    2024, 44(7):  72-85. 
    Asbtract ( )   PDF (8689KB) ( )  
    Related Articles | Metrics
    Efforts to eliminate institutional barriers hindering the mobility of labor and other factors of production are key tasks in the current construction of a unified national market For a long time,as a typical phenomenon of Chinas labor markets institutional segmentation,there has been a significant wage difference between stateowned enterprises (SOEs) and nonstateowned enterprises (nonSOEs) With the successful completion of the threeyear action plan for SOE reform from 2020 to 2022,Chinas stateowned enterprises have continuously improved their employment market mechanism At this stage,assessing the new characteristics of SOE relative to nonSOE wage premiums and analyzing their internal formation mechanisms is of great significance for further improving the marketoriented salary system of SOEs,deepening the marketoriented reform of labor factor markets,and advancing the integration of the domestic labor market 
    Using Chinese Enterprises Matching EmployerEmployee Data,this study employs quantile regression and counterfactual decomposition methods to examine the wage premium in stateowned enterprises (SOEs) and its formation mechanism from 2017 to 2021 The main conclusions of this study are as follows:Currently,there is a wage premium for SOEs relative to nonstateowned enterprises (nonSOEs),with the wage premium mainly concentrated in the middle and high income levels The main reason for the wage premium in SOEs is the segmentation of the labor market between SOEs and nonSOEs Further analysis indicates that at high wage levels,workplace vulnerable groups such as women and agricultural household registrants receive some compensation for salary discrimination,resulting in a larger SOE wage premium among these groups 
    Based on the above findings,this study proposes the following policy recommendations First,adhere to the direction of marketoriented reform for labor factor markets,further break down market segmentation,and especially facilitate the flow of labor between SOEs and nonSOEs in economically underdeveloped areas Second,further promote the marketoriented reform of the employment system in SOEs The next step of reform should focus on highincome groups such as managers in SOEs,strengthen performance assessments,and truly establish a marketoriented income formation mechanism where “staff can be promoted or demoted,and incomes can rise or fall” Lastly,strengthen the constraints against employment discrimination,particularly in private enterprises,to genuinely secure fair employment opportunities for vulnerable workplace groups like women and agricultural household registrants

    Corporate ESG Performance and Goodwill Impairment
    ZHOU Zejiang1, WANG Yichen2, LEI Ling1
    2024, 44(7):  86-102. 
    Asbtract ( )   PDF (10184KB) ( )  
    Related Articles | Metrics
    In recent years,substantial goodwill impairment of listed companies has attracted considerable attention Some companies have encountered operational crises and financial difficulties due to largescale goodwill impairment While substantial goodwill impairment harms investors interests,it also significantly undermines the overall stability of the capital market Therefore,exploring effective methods for identifying goodwill impairment is of great significance to protect investors rights and interests and to maintain the stability of the capital market 
    Currently,the assessment of corporate goodwill impairment predominantly relies on financial information,with relatively insufficient attention to nonfinancial information Corporate ESG performance,as a crucial piece of nonfinancial information,is closely related to corporate operations and development,potentially offering valuable insights for identifying goodwill impairment Therefore,investigating the applicability of corporate ESG performance in identifying goodwill impairment is a significant and valuable issue 
    Using Ashare listed companies in Chinas capital market from 2009 to 2021,this paper examines the relationship between corporate ESG performance and goodwill impairment The main findings are as follows Firstly,corporate ESG performance is significantly and negatively correlated with goodwill impairment,indicating that corporate ESG performance can be valuable information for identifying goodwill impairment Secondly,mechanism analysis reveals that good ESG performance suggests optimistic future operating performance and lower operating risks,thereby implying less goodwill impairment Thirdly,the negative relationship between ESG performance and goodwill impairment is more pronounced in nonstateowned companies and companies with lower institutional ownership or less analyst coverage Finally,this study finds that divergence in ESG ratings weakens the negative relationship between companies ESG performance and goodwill impairment 
    Compared to existing studies,this paper makes possible marginal contributions in three main aspects Firstly,it explores the informational value of companies ESG performance from the perspective of decision usefulness While existing research primarily focuses on how ESG performance information influences corporate behavior in the capital market,this paper emphasizes the intrinsic informational value of ESG performance,discussing the corporate traits embedded within it Secondly,it enriches the research literature on corporate goodwill impairment from an ESG perspective Although some studies have addressed the impact of corporate ESG performance on M&A goodwill,they have not thoroughly explored the inherent connection between corporate ESG performance and goodwill impairments This study provides new empirical evidence for understanding goodwill impairment in the context of sustainable development Thirdly,this paper links corporate ESG performance with goodwill impairment,providing valuable insights on the nonfinancial dimension for effectively identifying and preventing goodwill impairment risks

    The Macroeconomic Effects of Monetary Policy Expectations Management: Annotation of the Role of Liquidity Regulation
    YANG Yan1, YI Wei2
    2024, 44(7):  103-118. 
    Asbtract ( )   PDF (9285KB) ( )  
    Related Articles | Metrics
    China is facing a variety of shocks, such as geopolitical conflicts and trade unilateralism led by the United States, and the uncertainty in the economy is gradually rising and the expectations of economic agents are weakening Given the subjective nature of economic expectations, gradually rising uncertainty, especially economic policy uncertainty, is likely to lead economic agents to form distorted and confusing expectations of the economy, which will reduce the effectiveness of macroeconomic policies On the one hand, monetary policy is an important part of the steady growth relay of Chinas macroeconomic policy at present, and its regulatory effect is vulnerable to the uncertainty and the pressure of weakening expectations And on the other, in the process of monetary policy transmission to the real economy, commercial banks play a key role in liquidity rationing, so liquidity regulation will undoubtedly have a nonnegligible impact on monetary policy
    This paper not only introduces multiple frictions in the product and labor markets in the NKDSGE model, but also focuses on portraying the behavior of financial intermediaries, based on which it introduces liquidity regulation shocks to commercial banks, and examines the impact of liquidity regulation on the effects of monetary policy as well as macroeconomic fluctuations In addition, little empirical evidence has been provided in the literature on expected monetary policy shocks through theoretical modelling, this paper uses the text of the Peoples Bank of Chinas Monetary Execution Report to construct a central bank communication index, while using commercial bank data to construct a liquidity regulation index, and empirically studies the impact of central bank communication, a form of expectation management, and liquidity regulation on the macroeconomy through the SVAR model, as well as analyzing the central banks monetary policy response to expectation management and liquidity regulation
    It is found that:Firstly, recording to the estimated results based on SVAR model, monetary policy anticipation shocks can stimulate output growth and investment growth and trigger an accommodative monetary policy response from the central bank, whereas liquidity regulation has the effect of promoting investment and output growth but fettering liquidity expansion in the commercial banking system As regard to the numerical simulation of DSGE model, secondly, guiding economic agents to form expectations of monetary policy, which is conducive to the full realization of the regulatory function of monetary policy, and thirdly, liquidity regulation reduces the risk of commercial banks, is conducive to maintaining the health of the financial system, and has the effect of stimulating aggregate demand and stabilizing economic growth, but as liquidity regulation imposes constraints on the liquidity of the banking system, it will weaken the effect of monetary policy to a certain extent
    The findings of this paper have implications for strengthening monetary policy expectation management and promoting synergy between monetary policy and liquidity regulation

    National Governance Mechanisms in the Digital Age:Balancing Development and Security
    LI Jing1, NIE Huihua2
    2024, 44(7):  119-136. 
    Asbtract ( )   PDF (11401KB) ( )  
    Related Articles | Metrics
    Since the 18th National Congress of the Communist Party of China,China has accelerated its entry into the digital ageAt the same time,the national governance system,especially the official governance mechanism,has undergone significant changes:first,in terms of governance methods,from emphasizing incentives to emphasizing supervision;second,in terms of performance evaluation,from emphasizing a single economic indicator to emphasizing diversified indicators
    To rigorously examine the changes in the governance mechanisms of officials in the digital era,we construct an organizational economic model that includes the higherlevel government,who focus on both the development and the security,and subordinate officialsWe compare three typical contracts:developmentoriented contracts,securityoriented contracts,and multitask contracts,and the key findings are as follows:First,a developmentoriented contract is clearly preferable to a securityoriented contract,unless the security externalities are very large or the probability of a safety accident is very highSecond,if the principal cares about both development and security,she will definitely implement a performance evaluation mechanism of “onevote veto” for safety accidentsThird,an inverted Ushaped relationship exists between the supervision cost and the development orientationWhen the supervision cost is very high,the principal should adopt a developmentoriented performance evaluation mechanism;when the supervision cost is moderate,a multitask performance evaluation mechanism should be adopted;when the supervision cost is very low,a developmentoriented performance evaluation mechanism should be adoptedFourth,the greater the negative externality caused by safety accidents,the more inclined the principal is to adopt a multitask performance evaluation mechanism to ensure that the agent does not neglect safety issues while pursuing economic developmentOn the contrary,if the negative externality of safety accidents is relatively small,the principal may tend to adopt a performance evaluation mechanism that pays more attention to economic development
    Compared to existing literature,this paper integrates information technology with governance mechanisms,endogenizes information structures,and reemphasizes the value of supervisionIt expands the literature on incentive mechanisms and performance assessment from a dynamic perspective,arguing for the endogenous evolution of the assessment mechanism (in three stages)It also discusses a special type of nonlinear incentive mechanism,namely the onevote veto,and demonstrates its effective scopeThe research in this paper provides theoretical insights for optimizing official incentive mechanisms and for balancing development and security,and enriches the literature on Chinese official governance